Teardowns · · 4 min read
I'm Not Like Other Guys: A Line Teardown
I'm not like other guys
“I'm not like other guys” is a claim that asks to be believed before the claimant has done anything. Imagine she has posted a photograph of a jigsaw puzzle she finally finished after losing one piece for a week. He replies with a character reference for himself. The missing piece has been found; a new one has appeared in the comments.
The line's comic difficulty is that it sounds remarkably like a line. A person attempting to establish uniqueness has selected a sentence from the communal box of sentences.
A testimonial written by its subject
If someone tells you “I am unusually considerate,” you have learnt that they know the word considerate. You have not yet seen the evidence. The phrase “I'm not like other guys” works the same way. It offers a conclusion in place of the behaviour that might justify it. It is a review written by the product.
The phrase also leaves the comparison blank. Which guys? Not like them how? Does he enjoy crosswords? Does he own a small boat? Does he replace the lid on the toothpaste? The line relies on the listener filling the empty space with a flattering interpretation. He gets the benefit of every admirable difference without having to name one.
This is particularly odd under her puzzle post. She has supplied a story: the piece turned up inside the box lid, stuck to a strip of tape. A reply could celebrate the solve, ask what the finished picture is, or confess to a similar puzzle mishap. Instead he has arrived to announce his category status. He is, apparently, unlike other men in ways that make the puzzle less interesting.
The comparison has a cost
Like “you're not like other girls”, this line tries to build praise on an unnamed group. Here the praise is for the speaker himself. Other guys become a convenient shadowy mass; he steps out of it in his own description. The claim may be true in some respect. Everyone differs from everyone else in something. But without a specific action, the contrast is decorative.
There is an easy way to show that you are attentive: attend. Read the caption. Reply to the puzzle. Respect the fact that she may not want a conversation. None of those acts needs a speech about how rare they are. In fact, announcing your attentiveness beneath an ignored puzzle is rather poor evidence for attentiveness. The jigsaw has offered an unexpectedly rigorous test, and the line has failed it before the timer started.
What if he means “I'm safe to talk to”? That is not something a stranger can establish by declaration either. Trust comes from how an exchange actually goes, including whether a person notices boundaries and accepts a lack of response. A public comment that asks to be trusted on its own authority cannot shortcut that process. It can only make a claim and hope she performs the verification.
The puzzle would be a better introduction
Our imaginary jigsaw shows a seaside town with one tiny red boat. The lost piece completes a patch of sky. This is enough material for one ordinary human reply. “Where did the last piece turn up?” would have been a good question if the caption had not already answered it. Since the caption has, “That piece's week off seems excessive” might do. It is light, related to her post, and does not require a census of men.
The broader lesson is not that men must produce clever comments. They can be plain. “Glad you found it” is fine. The issue is the attempt to place the commenter's self-description ahead of the thing she wanted to share. The puzzle is an event in her life. His exceptional character, if real, can wait for a setting where she has expressed interest in meeting him.
There is also a strange request buried in the line: she is supposed to agree. “You do seem different,” perhaps, on the basis of one sentence. That is a lot of validation to ask from somebody who is still trying to decide where to hang a completed jigsaw. The burden is comically out of scale with the occasion.
The Copy-Paste Poet field note covers the hazard of reaching for familiar words and expecting them to sound personal.
The sleaze scale
Damp. The line is mild, but it asks a stranger to certify the speaker's character under a post that is not about him. Its worst feature is the confidence of an unsupported review.
There are more notices of self-awarded distinction in the bin. The puzzle needs no character references to be complete.
The missing piece was in the box all along.
Seen a worse line? Feed the bin.